Is This Only Entertainment?: My Click Moment and Why I Write About Games

One of the most common responses to feminist critiques–or indeed any sort of critiques–of games is, “It’s just a game!” Feminist critiques of games outside of specifically feminist blogs are often met with not just outright hostility in many cases, but an attitude of befuddlement; gamers wonder what is the point of writing about video games when women face so many other, bigger problems in the world. This is a question that has been answered over and over. Mighty Ponygirl from Feminist Gamers explained that video games contribute to sexist social conditioning:

…But behavior is more than just action — it’s a way of internalizing what is expected of you. Little girls are taught almost from birth to be quiet, compliant, passive, and that the most important thing is to be attractive to men. These lessons are reinforced when they play games that push women off in the corner to be rescued, or only allow them to pick up a sword if they’re wearing a bikini.

Andrea Rubenstein, aka tekanji, wrote a four-post series explaining why studying popular culture is important. One of her main points is that fighting oppression has to occur on many different levels and in different areas of or society:

Studying popular culture is probably my main focus, but since I love cross-sections I also keep abreast of other topics such as feminist issues, human sexuality, and general oppression work. I don’t think that this is inherently better or worse than someone who chooses one topic, or even a smaller subset of topics, to focus on.

In fact, I’d go one step farther to say that the only way I think we’ll ever have a chance at winning the battle against oppression (as much as one can “win” such a thing) is if we wage this war on multiple levels. I believe that every fight we fight — whether it be against domestic violence or raising our voices against the overabundance of “sexy girls who kick ass” in popular media — is a valuable one. I believe every stride we make, however small and however flawed, should be appreciated.

And I absolutely agree with both points. But there is something I would like to add, something I see as another reason writing about video games and popular culture in general is worthwhile: talking about pop culture is a great way to reach out to people. Not every feminist-minded individual is going to take a women’s studies course or pick up a bell hooks book from their library, but plenty of folks love discussing games, television, movies and so on on the internet. Looking at these things from a feminist perspective can introduce these concepts to people who may hold feminist ideals and just don’t know it yet.

I’m an example of this. Feminists sometimes talk about their “click moment”–the moment or event that led them to realize they were feminists. My click moment happened a little over two years ago. Ubisoft Montreal was promoting the shit out of Assassin’s Creed, a daring new IP that they hoped would turn into a franchise. The producer for the game was a woman named Jade Raymond, and in her role as producer she gave interviews and helped promote the game. The backlash she received from the online gaming community–as well as from so-called game “journalists” from Kotaku, Joystiq, and Destructoid–was swift and horrific, because she dared to be a woman speaking with authority about games.

It was my own outrage over the incident that led me to The IRIS Network and the aforementioned Feminist Gamers, as well as general feminism blogs like Feministe. I stayed up late night after night reading everything I could find, all these passionate and critical essays that put words to things that I had always known on some level, and opening my eyes to new manifestations of injustice that I’d never thought about before; I took the red pill and I never looked back.

But that one incident wasn’t the beginning of my feminist education, merely the catalyst that fused everything I had already learned and seen with newfound knowledge, giving me the tools to describe all those events that made me deeply uncomfortable in my gut but I hadn’t been able to explain. I’d had plenty of lessons before then on oppression, even if I didn’t know what to call it. And a lot of them came from fandom, the feminists and womanists and social justice advocates who cared enough to call people out in various venues. I clearly remember, ten years or so ago when I was still in middle school, getting educated on what “sexual orientation” means and why it’s wrong to assume everyone is straight until they say otherwise, on the now-defunct FanFiction.Net mailing list, of all places. It was a webcomic that first introduced me to the idea that sex and gender are two different things. During the first season of Heroes, I learned about subtle racist biases from a post about racism and the show on the heroes_tv LJ community.

And I learned more and more about feminism every day on the girl_gamers LJ comm, where feminists weighed in on sexism-related drama that popped up fairly often, and every time I would learn something new, or someone would put words to an issue that was previously only a minor itch at my brain that told me something is wrong here.

All of these people prepped me for my click moment simply by participating in fandom, by talking about their favorite shows and games in their own way, braving the inevitable backlash and meeting it head-on. I benefited so much from these discussions, though many of the participants were never aware of it.

My greatest hope with my writing is that I can pay the favor forward as much as possible. I try to reach people in a different way than scholarly writing does; and while this may not be the most convincing reason games are a worthwhile topic of feminist discussion, it’s an important one to me, because it is deeply intertwined with my understanding of both topics. I know I’ve already succeeded once; I received an email a few months ago from a GameCritics.com reader who had enjoyed my article about gender and Mass Effect. As he described how he had been ravenously reading the Feminism 101 blog and suddenly everything made more sense, I realized I’d given someone their own click moment. It reminded me of all those lessons I’d learned, and how the seemingly frivolous act of chatting about games on the internet can actually be important, even if you think games are “only” entertainment. And that’s why I write about games.

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “Is This Only Entertainment?: My Click Moment and Why I Write About Games

  1. Well if that last paragraph isn’t about me it certainly describes me. I personally think it’s a good idea to include Pop Culture in whatever subject you’re trying to discuss and games are a major part of Pop Culture now. Just look at the presence of games at ‘cons like Comic-Con. Games are the new media, and it’s important we look at them from every angle and ask the authors of this new media to be responsible for the images and stories their games portray. Also, we need to figure out a way to lock Orson Scott Card out.

    • Also, we need to figure out a way to lock Orson Scott Card out.

      Seriously. My mind boggles at the fact that he keeps getting deals with game companies. The Dragon Age thing was some EPIC FAIL though. What kind of cognitive dissonance could have led to the decision to allow a vocal homophobe creative license over an expressly queer-friendly product?

      • It really makes no sense at all unless the decision came from on-high (EA games). I suspect this is likely the case. I also suspect the expansion in march was going to be DLC.

        At any rate, I read this: http://www.gamepro.com/article/features/213466/bayonetta-empowering-or-exploitative/ today and now I’m a bit confused about how I feel about that game, so please play it through and write up your feelings on it. And also tell me how to get past chapter 3 on normal mode. Seriously though, after reading that I looked back at a scene in the very beginning of the game and realized there was a role reversal at play. In your standard swashbuckling tale the male lead loses his sword and looks screwed until his love interest hanging out in the background tosses him a weapon at the very last minute to defeat the villian. In the opening scene of Bayonetta she requires a constant stream of firearms, which are tossed to her by a man who later on assumes official sidekick status, elsewhere another man serves as the wacky sidekick who constantly almost gets killed. I could go on about her super-hyper-over-the-top sexuality but the article i linked deffinately covers it, one thing they missed was a bit of camp added in with vibration linked to odd things (ala xena “whoosh” noises) like unholstering a gun.

      • Right, I’m not even sure EA had any hand in it. I wouldn’t be surprised if this were all the comic publisher’s doing. Not that that is any excuse.

        That’s interesting about Bayonetta (what you point out, not that article, which frankly I can’t even bring myself to read; I can’t get past the title, even, since it sets up a false dichotomy between empowering and exploitative). Unfortunately I don’t have the time or inclination to buy the game and play it, but soon Denis should be getting a copy, and he will definitely be writing about it for The Border House.

      • I’m further in and the game is still very very confusing as to what it is trying to do. The campiness and the reversed gender roles mixed with the titular character’s insane over the top sexuality makes me think it is some sort of commentary on media depictions of women especially in games. Or maybe it’s just straight up exploitative?

        I’m not really sure yet but I am sure that I want to unlock one of the costumes that includes a more traditional witch’s hat. Be sure to pass on to Denis that the key to the game in most places is dodge dodge hit dodge dodge hit, don’t fall for the rush in beatdown.

        But yeah you’re right about the false dichotomy but it seems like those are all over the place, just watch some politics on TV and wait for the commentator to ask “is so-and-so a communist or a fascist?”.

    • Too true about getting Orson out. Really though, I consider myself fairly in tune with the internet and I missed the whole comic issue. I bring up Jade Redmond a lot because I don’t know very many female contributors to great games the way I know Sid Meyers and Will Wright. But I’ve been a fan of every game Jade’s been a part of from Beyond Good and Evil forward.

      I take my game feminism on a case by case basis, but what I would encourage is that if I am playing a game my feminist minded friends find offensive, they should bring it up. Some games are flat tacky. Some games are just awesome. And some parts of some games are bound to be left unquestioned by myself and I don’t mind at all when they are. I tend to prefer those who question more than those people who don’t as like minds and good folks for conversations and fellow citizenry and all.

  2. You really know how to make a girl miss blogging terribly, don’t you? 😛

    Excellent article; it reminded me a lot of my own “click” moment (brought to me via fandom_wank of all places) and everything that led up to it.

  3. Pingback: SideQuesting » Blog Archive » Interview: Alexandra Raymond, The Border House

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s